Anyone who knows me well knows that I was raised in a "Modern
Family" type situation, though really, there's nothing particularly
strange about it. I was raised by a single mother until I was 14 and she
remarried, earning me three stepbrothers (two the biological children of my
stepfather, one from my stepfather's second marriage). My mother and
stepfather divorced when I was about 22. Though I still have some ties to
my stepfamily, my mother is my main relation, let's say,
though I do have an expansive and complicated "immediate" family,
like many Americans.
I bring this up because this not so atypical family shaped my
world views. As a blended family, the stepbrother who was closest in age to me
lived with us. He attended a relatively multi-cultural public school
while I attended a predominately white private college prep school on a
minority/merit scholarship. As a result, both in high school and as
adults, most of my friends are white, while most of his friends are black.
Jump forward a little bit in the logic here with me: my parents (all of them)
are black. My stepbrother's friendships, while sometimes not the best,
were generally respected and encouraged, while I was sometimes lectured on the
pitfalls of moving in white society and having white friends (mostly by my
stepfather). *Note: There were eight minority students in my graduating
class. Three of us were black, me, female, and two males. I was
casual friends with one, but none of us really hung out in the same circles,
which made my stepfather's insistence that I wasn't trying hard enough to have
black friends rather ridiculous. A later university experience in which
he and my mother drove to my campus and insisted that the head of
multi-cultural affairs force me to join black student groups was another
shining example of my family's general wackiness. The best I can describe
this is to liken it to being a third generation American who is relatively assimilated, but has parents who don't remember the
"old country" but cling to the community.*
So with that background, I will begin this post.
As I have mentioned, my husband and I are currently living
overseas and about to move back to the US, in about four months. We have
a unique opportunity to plan many things that most people can't: exactly where
to buy a house, what kind of car to get (we plan on one), and most importantly,
when to have children. I was recently back in the US for an extended
holiday and took this chance to further explore possible locations, since it is
still a bit too soon to buy a house.
As two professionals with college degrees and a taste for urban
living, our choices seem easy. Around the greater DC area, there are
plenty of great communities that can suit your life style. In the spirit
of planning where to live, this is what we want:
- A walkable community with parks, restaurants, and some shopping
(like being able to hop off the bus and get milk/veg/whatever)
- Access to public transportation (we want one car when we start
out)
- A house or townhouse with 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, possibly a
half bath
- A short commute into the city, highway accessible for a commute
out of the inner suburbs (the chances of one of us working in the city while
the other works further out is high)
- Good schools, safe neighborhood
I think most people would agree that these are common desires for
a couple about to embark on the insane path to starting a family. (We could
continue on as DINKs and
enjoy a high quality lifestyle full of fun and travel...) But apparently,
these desires are laced with all sorts of pitfalls: racism, classism, elitism, etc.
A good example is this: When I went back, I had a few Sunday
afternoons dedicated to open houses in the neighborhoods I was considering,
which I attended with my mother. Prior to these open houses, we had some
lengthy conversations about what I wanted. My mother wanted to know why I
wanted to live in certain neighborhoods over others. To be fair, I am
particularly fixated on the qualities of schools, having gone to five public
schools, one parochial school, and one preparatory academy. I want to
believe in public schools, but I want to get the best I can for my tax dollars.
When I explained this notion, my mother recoiled a bit. By
expressing our desire to actually use the public school system, but aim for the
best ones, she wanted to know why I thought it was so important.
Studies show that people choose homes based on the record of
school districts or even a school, whenever possible. Plenty of internet advice pages on how to buy a house suggest
considering this even if you don't have children or plan to use the public
school system. It increases the desirability of a house. So imagine
me feeling a bit flustered that this was even a question. Why choose the
best schools? My mother felt that I was wasting my time - that if we just
found a place to live, we'd find that the school would be "good
enough" once we had children, and we could not predict whether a school or
school district would be the same when said hypothetical child entered it in 6+
years. My argument was that rather not leave that to chance, if at all
possible. Additionally, while being no expert, I feel that I can safely
estimate that a school district will not improve by more than 10-20% (that
would be huge) in five years. Even if our kid doesn't go to that school
and we move, the chances that whoever follows us is looking for a good school
is high.
The next thing that my mother thought was a bit odd was my
fixation on test scores and poverty levels at various schools in the "good school districts". This is where I think the idea of a "blacklash" (my poor attempt at a pun on backlash) comes in. Schools with
high levels of poor students are generally serve working class and/or minority communities. This is not always true, but in Arlington and Alexandria it is. Arlington can actually be divided into areas based
on this. On a broad level, the north part of Arlington has very low numbers of low-income students, really high home prices, and more houses. It also lacks decent public transportation, but has the highest number of high achieving schools in the county. Middle Arlington is more balanced, averaging 20% low-income students in its schools, but still has high home prices. This is probably because Middle Arlington also has a relatively large amount of reasonably priced apartments, where older cheaper units are typically inhabited by working class families and luxury units by singles and childless couples. The Orange line runs right through this part of Arlington, keeping rents high near the Metro, even in poorer complexes. South Arlington in a bit more unique. It has pockets of impressively low income neighborhoods, which are surprisingly focused around certain schools (Arlington is highly Democratic). It also has areas that
are well balanced between working and middle class,
great public transit,
though focused more around buses. The schools in this area vary, but the "good" ones manage to serve low-income and middle income families well, having 30-50% low income students, but high test scores. This is where I am aiming to live, if we can find a house.
I guess my shock came that my mother took my thoughts on this as partially racist or at least turning my back on the black community in some ways. "What about having your kids go
to the school and being a good influence on others?" she asked. A valid point, I admit, but I would rather
have the even crazier parents be an influence on me, so that my kid is even better off. I'm not looking for schools where there are no minorities, that would be nuts, but I don't want my kid going to school with all minorities. In a perfect world, the school would reflect the broader community and have a mix of rich, middle, and poor and all races. We don't live in that world and Arlington doesn't randomly mix up all the schools. So unfortunately, it’s much easier to look for the wealth, i.e., white schools and be assured of better results than for other criteria. Man, maybe that does make me a bad person...
The whole idea that my mother thought that I shouldn't worry so much about where we lived smacked of hypocrisy to me. As I mentioned, I went to five elementary schools. I am not a military brat. My mother simply wasn't happy with
the education/daycare/location of
my school. This ended up being profoundly disruptive, as unlike military kids, there was no support network for being tossed around like this. In the end, I attended a public school that was in our working class
neighborhood and featured children bused in
from the projects.
While I was a relatively average student, from 3rd to 5th grade, I was educated with children routinely 2-3 years older than
me. In 5th grade, half of our class was 11 years old, the other half, 14. I can tell you that there were definitely different things on each group's minds.
Key to much of
this is that my husband and I are actively planning to start a family. We didn't get married and just throw the birth control away - we are waiting for that moment when our "stars" align: he has a new job, we have a house, and we're back in the US. If it goes according to plan, nothing will be an accident, which now precipitates buying a house... somewhere, finding daycare... somewhere, getting by... somehow. I don't know if my mother flat out resents my fierce desire to control my life or if she too once thought like this and sees folly where I see wisdom.
The other thing that quite took me by surprise was my mother's dismissive attitude about where we wanted to live in regards to how much of a commute we wanted. After looking at houses for three Sundays in a row, my mother began to
say, "These houses are expensive, why don't you just live in Lorton/Quantico/Fredericksburg/Springfield? You can take the train to work." My response was that I wanted a commute of no more than one hour. She thought the train ride was less than
an hour. She was not factoring in the time it took to get to the train, being on the train, getting off and taking the metro, walking to work, taking a shuttle, etc. Additionally, unimportant in her mind was the desire to live where we wanted to live.
It'll be good enough, she
said. For that longer commute, I could have a much bigger house on my salary.
Many people feel this way and commit to that type of existence. However, I do not. Yes, I get this great cost of living allowance to live in the DC metro area. The government doesn't force me to live in a prescribed distance from work. But that doesn't mean I want to spend 4 hours a day commuting just to save money. As the child of a single parent, who will one day be the parent of a child with two working parents, I remember the importance of spending time with your kids. Spending 4 hours commuting is time I won't be home. Two hours roundtrip is my tolerance anyhow, which I learned years ago, not to mention that most people my age would rather take public transit when possible (it frees you up to do something else on your commute). That extra money I make means nothing if I'm miserable in my extra long commute. Being the fastidious planner that I am, it makes much more sense to improve my quality of life in the areas I care about: a comfortable commute and a comfortable home. No McMansions needed.
That said, I do notice a trend: most of my friends prefer to live close in. Most of my friends and colleagues who do this tend to be white. It's the minorities who are usually commuting from the outer reaches of the metro area.
This probably goes to economics as well, as the close in
inner suburbs are being revitalized into ideal places to live and poor, mostly minority families are pushed further out. While I don't like the idea of people being pushed out, I'm not
about to schlep in
for some bizarre solidarity moment. Notably, my mother, who went to a mostly while junior and senior high, prefers to associate with black people. She was raised Lutheran,
but chose to raise me African Methodist Episcopal (I'm a secular humanist now). I sometimes think that she may feel as if my life choices are a repudiation of her parenting choices; I feel as if this was the logical conclusion: you sent me to schools with white people, of course I married a white man and have white friends and want to live among people with the same educational background and values.
Anyhow, none of the areas she
mentioned are remotely appealing to me. I told her as much, but that didn't stop her from trying to convince me otherwise.
Surprisingly, at least one
of my good friends agreed with
my point of view, while another pretty much teased me for wanting to live among our supposed peer group and do as they do. She dubbed Arlington's wealthier schools the priva-public school system, which is likely true; home prices discriminate much in the same way expensive private schools do. Those who can afford to live there perpetuate the cycle of
a well to do school that is not really public in the way most people think of it. But on the other hand, those wealthy schools seem to have the largest number of mixed race children, which is what I will have. The middle tier schools have a fair number as well, along with other races, but at those wealthy schools, mixed raced children are the largest group after white ones in many cases. Food for thought it seems.
But really, I can't really say how much of my ideas of the ideal neighborhood
is offensive and to who. It seems at least somewhat disturbing to my mother: how could I want to live in a nice, safe place with good schools? But then, she doesn't believe public schools are good anyway. I figure if I'm not going to be exempt from the taxes that pay for them, I'm going to get my money's worth, unless, for some reason, our kid needs another type of environment, but that's a whole other
situation. I do wonder, though, if there are
others who experience blacklash - is it wrong to
be what your parents seemingly wanted for you? I feel as though if my parents didn't want this life for me, they could have left me in public school or moved to Atlanta and found an all black prep school for me. But even in
public school, while my friends were predominantly black, I had plenty of white ones and as I got older, my friends got whiter, even then. Maybe it was all predetermined, the minute I started acting out scenes from Return of the Jedi on the playground...
Maybe there's more to it than that - by being moderately successful, do I owe something to the black community? I've heard people say yes and no. Those on the yes side tend to believe that if one is successful, you must help your community, by patronizing black businesses, doctors,
and organizations. Others like me, dare I
say, Oreos, might see if differently. A whole other conversation can be had on Oreos and the race card, but in short, I had my card pulled a long time ago. Would I like to be part of the black community? Probably. But am I welcome? Just about as much as Barack Obama when he isn't giving us jobs: everyone is proud that we have a black president, but many black people think he owes them something because of his skin. I tend to feel the same way when dealing with other blacks: I don't sound black,
so there's something wrong, I'm not Christian so I'm a traitor,
and I don't really fit into
the black community so I'm not trusted. Not real reasons to want to go out of my way. Granted, there are wealthy black communities in Maryland, but I can't afford to
live there and I prefer Virginia.
I'd like to think I'm part of a broader America that is equal and
fair. At best, I am a woman and well educated and I will take what doors that opens any day. But I guess, don't hate me
because I want to live the life I feel is best and have the cash to do it.
**Note: There's a book called Blacklash out there, so I guess the term belongs to that author, though I'm not sure we're using in the same way.
**Note: There's a book called Blacklash out there, so I guess the term belongs to that author, though I'm not sure we're using in the same way.